I got an email from another member of my team today that was asking for some suggestions on how his customer should handle a tenant issue.  Here is his opening email:

I have a client that is very green in the rental business. He signed a lease with a tenant for 6 months.  The tenant moved in but hasn’t paid him a dime.  No month in advance, deposit, rent etc.  What can be done to get this person out?

Ouch!  Now, I suspect that 90% of new landlords have made the mistake of not getting a security deposit prior to move in, at least once in their career.  In my experience (and I have made this mistake before), you will get that deposit only about 10% of the time.  Once they move in, you have zero leverage to get that deposit.  That tenant has no fear of you actually doing anything to them.  In fact, you can’t!  No eviction in the world is going to work to get that deposit paid.

When the tenant signs the lease, you should get the damage deposit.  And before they move in, you should get the first month’s rent.  Worst case, if the time is short, get all of it prior to move in.  If the time is long between lease signing and move in, always get a deposit as the tenant can simply walk away from the lease.  While you could try to sue them for lost rent, good luck.  Actually, you could get into a wierd situation where legally you need to evict them to break the lease even if they never lived there.  Worst case, hold the keys until they give you the security deposit and first month’s rent.  This is the last leverage you have.

Another mistake that I am sure happens, but I made only once in my earlier landlord years was to accept a personal check for the deposit and/or first month’s rent.  I am sure you can guess what happens next; the check bounces.  Now you have a tenant living in your investment property that has not paid anything to be there.  Much like the guy above.  If you have several weeks prior to move-in, you have time for a personal check to clear.  Also, if the check is drawn on a local bank, drive it over there and have it cashed immediately so you get the funds directly instead of depositing in your bank, they send it to the tenant’s bank and then it gets returned 14 days later NSF.

A slight twist on this mistake is when you are dealing with a tenant that get’s a rental subsidy like Section 8.  The tenant talks the talk like they know exactly how it all works, saying they have talked to this person or that agency and you are going to get your money.  Never take the tenant’s word for it.  Call the agency or have the tenant provide written proof of the subsidy.  Just because they say they are getting emergency assistance to pay the security deposit, doesn’t mean they qualify for it.

Taking some precautions and holding the keys ransom for the money is the best option.  By they way, I told this agent to file the eviction immediately (since they also owed the first month’s rent).